Red Deer Commission (1990) Annual Report for 1989. Methods for control of wild deer appropriate for use in the urban environment in England. [10] By that time, the range of red deer had spread out around their previous range in the Highlands, with particular expansions into the Eastern Highlands and southwards in the Central Highlands towards the Central Belt. 12 Since the 1970s, distribution maps for deer species have tended to be based on the presence or absence of deer in 10 kilometre squares. Also see: Forestry Commission Scotland (2014), Deer Management on the National Forest Estate: Current Practice and Future Directions 1 April 2014 to 31 March 2017. Landowners however also have a responsibility for the welfare of deer and their natural habitat. Fallow deer are native to mainland Europe and have a long history in Scotland, having first been introduced to Scotland as park deer in the 13th century. 11 DCS response to Freedom of Information Request about red deer counts in Dumfries and Galloway, 15 April 2010. The Management of Wild Red Deer in Scotland. BSP, London. The guides are developed within Scotland’s deer sector to provide you with the best information available on wild deer management. Advocates for Animals’ ... We believe that the central principle in any management of wild deer should be that the culling of deer should be kept to an absolute minimum. 981. Deer Management Scotland All deer are wild species and only become someone’s property when they are captured or killed by persons entitled by law to do so – usually the owners of the land on which they are present. 29 The commentary above reflects, firstly, that the national populations estimates given by SNH in 2013 and since, are not based on “population counts” beyond incorporating the open hill red deer counts in the estimates for that species. Our roe deer has featured on the Great British Menu and we export abroad, We have a stall at Kelso Farmers Market. 51 The largest single contributor to the annual cull totals is Forestry and Land Scotland (FLS), which manages Scotland’s National Forest Estate (NFE) on behalf of Scottish Ministers. ;] However, the distribution of the culls in Scotland can be illustrated by sub-dividing national statistics by Local Authority area. (eds.) It was responsible for the conservation, control and sustainable management of all species of wild deer in Scotland. In the speculative example using SNH’s estimates as described above, SNH’s national cull statistics may only be recording around 60% of Scotland’s national cull each year. 9 Ratcliffe, P. (1987). The number of deer shot in Scotland has also increased considerably over that time. 32 SNH (2016) Op cit. assess STEC prevalence in wild deer faeces in Scotland; review cross-contamination risks in the slaughter and processing stages of wild deer from the field to larder ; Although the prevalence of STEC O157 in wild deer is low, the report found that when discovered, it is the strain associated with the most severe forms of human disease. Report to Defra. [28] The national totals were the same except that the fallow population was estimated at 2,000 compared to 8,000. A deer manager will get more value from a deer census if the data is used together with information such as the condition of the habitats. 20 Swanson, G., Campbell, D. and Armstrong, H. (2008). 23 In a wider review published in 1995 shortly before the 1959 Act was replaced by the 1996 Act, Harris et al gave a higher estimate of 347,000 for the number of red deer in Scotland. 56 The land use types used by SNH are broad and undefined and, for example, most deer killed on agricultural land are likely to be resident in adjoining woodland. 1 Gilbert, J. [25] As a result of their review of available sources, Harris et al also gave a substantially higher estimate of Scotland’s roe population (350,000), while giving similar estimates to those of the RDC for sika and fallow. This stems from the agreement by Scottish Ministers and the Scottish Parliament’s Rural Affairs, Climate Change and Environment Committee that a review of deer management in Scotland be undertaken in 2016. However, the Group had anticipated that SNH might have considered those maps too coarse grained at 10 kilometre squares for its purposes. Forestry Commission Bulletin 128. Section 17 Non-Native Deer Species. Wild Deer a National Approach is a strategy produced in 2008 which sets out guiding principles, objectives, key actions and tools for deer management. While visual counts can be made of red deer on open hill range, indirect methods such as dung counting techniques have to be used in woodlands to try to assess deer numbers. Public confidence in these three issues is essential if wild deer management in Scotland is to maintain the understanding and respect of a wider audience at home and abroad. However, the percentages in Figure 13 illustrate a range of points about the national cull. SNH referred the Group to the estimates in its evidence to the Scottish Parliament’s RACCE Committee in 2013. The national population estimates given in those two sources are shown in Figure 6. HMSO, Edinburgh. [51] While the Highland Council area dominates the statistics because it accounts for 33% of the total land area and 39% of the total cull, Figure 11 shows that some other areas such as Perth and Kinross have higher cull levels relative to their size. They were introduced in ornamental deer parks in 1860, and are now living in the wild. [36] The total is described as the “most recent” estimate that “was documented in the report to RACCE in 2013”. The guides are dynamic and practitioners are encouraged to debate and share ideas to help develop future editions. However, it did not publish the total annual red deer culls recorded by the returns in its Annual Reports until 1973. 55 A further perspective on the national cull statistics can be obtained by dividing them according to the land use types where the deer were culled. [49] FLS publishes its annual cull totals and Figure 32 in Section 14 of this Report shows these totals for each deer species for 2009-2018, including the cull totals from its predecessor, Forest Enterprise Scotland, as a percentage of the national cull statistics. SPICe Briefing 13/74. As … • Deer management provides a number of socio-economic benefits including supporting employment, contributing to rural tourism, providing sporting income and the sale of venison. [53] Figure 13 shows the national cull statistics sub-divided by land use type for both each species and the overall cull for the five years 2011-16. An expert report has called for hundreds of thousands of deer to be culled in Scotland to deal with an unsustainable surge in numbers.. It supports a voluntary approach to deer management but also outlines how and when NatureScot may get involved. Including 2015-2020 Priorities. [23] However, the report in 1990 appears to be the first occasion that it published estimates for all four species. The Management of Wild Deer in Scotland – Report of the Deer Working Group. The results in Figure 10 suggest over 70,000 additional deer, which would indicate an actual total cull of over 180,000. 47 The Group considers that SNH’s speculative estimates appear reasonable, based on its experience and other consultations. Code of Practice on Deer Management. Principles of Scotland’s Wild Deer: A National Approach Provide a Scottish framework to guide local decision-making and improve delivery of deer management. Dear Cabinet Secretary. The final report of the Deer Working Group. Distribution and current status of Sika Deer, Cervus Nippon, in Great Britain. Despite the importance of the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) genes for immune response, assessment of diversity on these genes is still rare for European deer populations. The guides within this folder have been developed by Scotland's deer sector to provide you with the best information available on wild deer management in a format that is easy to access. It also stresses the importance of managing deer collaboratively, of talking to neighbours and of planning together. By continuing to use this site, you agree to our use of cookies. 23 The 1980 estimate was 150,000-175,000, cited in: Harris, S., Morris, P., Wray, S. and Yalden, D. (1995), A review of British mammals: population estimates and conservation status of British mammals other than cetaceans, JNCC report. Find The report estimates that up to 1 million wild deer … An example is the Scottish Government’s ‘Wild Deer: A National Approach’. 29 Edwards, T. and Kenyon, W. (2013). While SNH considers the overall population of red deer on open hill range in the Highlands to be no longer increasing, the evidence available suggests that the overall deer populations elsewhere in Scotland continue to increase due to more habitat availability, expanding range and climate change. out more about cookies, Coronavirus (COVID-19): what you need to know. The Report is a commendably comprehensive account of the history of deer management and deer legislation in … [20], 21 When the Red Deer Commission (RDC) was established by the Deer (Scotland) Act 1959, Scotland’s population of red deer was estimated to be around 155,000. (2005). Red deer are the largest, and if you visit in late September and October you can watch the rut, one of the animal kingdom's greatest spectacles. It also acted as the Government's advisor on deer-related matters. [2] That century is considered the low point for the numbers of both species in Scotland, with the main concentrations of red deer surviving in parts of the Central Highlands around Atholl, Black Mount, Glenartney, Glen Fiddich, Invercauld and Mar.[3]. [6], 6 Scotland’s two non-native species of wild deer, fallow and sika, had also become established at a number of locations by the 20th century due to escapes and deliberate releases from the deer parks kept by some land owners. (1920). [30] SNH confirmed to the Group that these were also the sources of its estimates to the RACCE Committee. 19 The Group considers that SNH should develop more detailed distribution maps using the returns that it can require land owners and occupiers to submit of the species, numbers and sexes of the deer shot on their land. Control of Wild Deer in Scotland – Authorisations Guidance for Practitioners Purpose of this document This document outlines the legal framework surrounding the control of wild deer in Scotland including the role of Authorisations in permitting activities that would otherwise be an offence. 33 SNH did not mention national population estimates for sika and fallow deer in their 2016 report. The need for deer management For many people deer stalking is a recreational activity, but it is also necessary to protect agricultural crops, forestry, native flora and indeed, deer, since they are prolific breeders and, if numbers are allowed to increase unchecked, may become prone to starvation and disease. The Group considers that SNH should be much more accurate meantime in reporting the dates and sources of the national population estimates that it currently uses. 10 The maps in Figure 4 show the distribution of the four wild deer species in Scotland by 1990, shortly before the Deer (Scotland) Act 1996 replaced the 1959 Act. Scotland’s Wild Deer: A National Approach is the strategic vision for deer management in Scotland. They show, for example, that only a small proportion of the culls are on agricultural land, although there is a noticeably higher proportion for fallow. A factor in this has been the increase in the number of cull returns obtained from land owners by the DCS and then SNH over the period.[45]. Any data collected is anonymised. [33] However, the report concluded that, after decades of increases, the size of the open hill red deer population had levelled out during the last 10-20 years. This policy covers the Scottish Wildlife Trust’s views on the management of all species of wild deer in Scotland. In other words, Balmoral and its neighbours are amongst the worst estates in Scotland in their approach to deer management and this requires effective intervention at … In Scotland, any persons wishing to sell large wild game require to be Licensed Venison Dealers (Deer (Scotland) Act 1996, unless they are selling directly to or purchasing directly from a LVD. 11 The maps also show the major spread of roe deer, while the scattered distributions of the fallow and sika populations reflected the patterns of their original escapes or releases. 58 Despite a succession of public bodies responsible for the management of all four species for nearly 40 years since 1982, the picture at a national level is still unclear. 17.3 Muntjac Deer. Gov.scot uses cookies which are essential for the site to work. We also collect and maintain national data on deer management, and support the development of Wild Deer Best Practice guidance. 43 The RDC reported cull return totals to 15 February each year until the early 1990s, with that date being the last day of the shooting seasons for female sika, red/sika hybrids and fallow. The notion that Scotland could sustain an annual roe cull twice the currently recorded level, seems a reasonable proposition to the Group. This level of annual mortality could be considered to suggest that the overall population of wild deer in Scotland is higher than the previous estimates that SNH cites and could potentially be approaching a million. The Deer Working Group is an independent working group appointed by Scottish Ministers in October 2017, to recommend changes to ensure effective deer management in Scotland that safeguards public interests and promotes the sustainable management of wild deer. (1991) The Management of Wild Red Deer in Scotland, Rural Forum, Scotland. The following summary was written to provide some historical context for the consideration of changes to the law in the current Land Reform Bill, including the recent amendments on deer management from Mike Russell MSP. All deer are wild species and only become someone’s property when they are captured or killed by persons entitled by law to do so – usually the owners of the land on which they are present. These estimates are given in Figure 6. A joint Scottish Natural Heritage/Forestry Commission/Scottish Government project awarded funding through the Scottish Government's Contract Research Fund and undertaken in collaboration with Scotland's Rural College (SRUC). Delivering effective deer management that safeguards public interests and promotes the sustainable management of wild deer. Ungulates and their management in Great Britain and Ireland. Scottish Natural Heritage Commissioned Report No. Deer Management Groups We support the work of the Association of Deer Management Groups (ADMG) and Lowland Deer Network Scotland (LDNS) in their efforts to represent the full range of interests involved in deer management and their work to encourage and deliver sustainable deer management across Scotland. 28 Scottish Parliament, Written Answer Report, S4W-17132, 2 October 2013. Google Scholar Cameron, A.G. (1923) The Wild Red Deer of … 14 The 2016 distribution maps show that red deer have continued to expand their range into the north-east of Scotland and south into the Central Belt, with the population in Southern Scotland also spreading further. The report estimates that up to 1 million wild deer … Get this from a library! Wild deer in Scotland belong to no-one – in legal terms they are res nullius. In its Constitution, ADMG’s role is described as: 12 Ward, A. The Group also considers that, as with information on deer distributions, greater use by SNH of the cull return system to cover more of the country would help give clearer indications of the numbers of deer in different areas and identify trends both locally and nationally.[42]. Habitat Impact Assessment: Best Practice Guidance on the Management of Wild Deer in Scotland. This was developed and is being delivered by private and public bodies working together. Read the Code of Practice on Deer Management. The Deer Working Group is an independent working group appointed by Scottish Ministers in October 2017, to recommend changes to ensure effective deer management in Scotland that safeguards public interests and promotes the sustainable management of wild deer. 60 Estimates of the national population sizes of the deer species are destined to be of limited accuracy and might be considered of limited value beyond a general indication of trends. 46 The fact that the ‘national cull statistics’ published by SNH do not represent the actual total cull of each species in Scotland each year, is a significant distinction that appears often not to be recognised. out more about cookies, Cabinet Secretary for Environment, Climate Change and Land Reform. View a map of Post-2000 deer densities from Deer Commission Scotland data. On the annual cull return forms used by SNH, it asks the respondents to record the numbers of deer they cull under one of three dominant land use types: agriculture, woodland or open range. 33 Albon, S.D., McLeod, J., Potts, J., Brewer, M., Irvine, J., Towers, M., Elston, D., Fraser, D. and Irvine, J. Habitat Impact Assessment as explained in the Best practice Guides (BPGs) is a methodology for measuring and assessing current impact of grazing on habitats. Simon Pepper is a former director of WWF Scotland (1985-2005) and Deer Commissioner (2005-10) keen to see deer management delivering a better outcome for all interests. [16] Similarly, fallow deer have also expanded over that period with a number of previously localised populations coalescing over wider areas. [41] The Group’s view is that the statement should also have included sika and fallow deer. Red Deer Commission (1990) Evidence to the Agricultural Select Committee, in Land Use and Forestry, HMSO, Edinburgh. Despite the number of assumptions, this probably provides the most realistic population estimation for Scotland”.[37]. ATV Qualification Units 208/209 (City & Guilds) EFAW + F. DMQ AW's. However, it is now 60 years since the 1959 Act first introduced a statutory framework to regulate deer hunting rights to protect public interests. Red deer meat, or Venison, is becoming increasingly popular, the demand for which is being partly met by farmed Deer. [12] The total number of squares occupied by each species in Britain in 1972, 2002 and 2007 have also been compared to show the on-going expansion in the distribution of each species. This policy supports Scottish Wildlife Trust’s broader vision for a network of healthy and resilient ecosystems 1 across Scotland where wild deer can be part of flourishing, ecologically functional living landscapes. It has been organised around the five 'Scotland's Wild Deer: A National Approach' (WDNA) priorities, allowing you to filter the information based on your interests.. However, the Group considers that SNH should have a clearer account of the current position with each species, rather than their “most recent estimates” being based on estimates made 10 years or more ago and some of which appear out of date. Consultation on Strategy for Wild Deer Deer Commission for Scotland . Control and mitigation of disease in wild ungulate populations are one of the major challenges in wildlife management. [38] It is not clear how this estimate relates to the higher estimates for roe quoted above. Wild Deer Resource Scotland. In: Apollonio, M., Andersen, R. and Putman, R. Deer management groups, often on sporting estates, kill certain numbers, but SEL wants the Scottish government to set and enforce higher targets. Deer Management Scotland. [24] This estimate took account of the estimates by Clutton-Brock and Albon (1989) for red deer in Scotland (297,000+/-40,000) and by Staines and Ratcliffe (1987) for the numbers of red deer in woodlands (27,000-50,000). 61 There is also the implication from the information on distributions and population sizes that, overall, the current levels of the annual culls of each species nationally are less than population growth. 15 The Group is very grateful to the British Deer Society for all its help in producing these maps. Get in touch Wild Scotland Suite 212 8 Church Street Inverness IV1 1EA info@wild-scotland.co.uk Red Deer Commission. (1979). Scotland’s Wild Deer: A National Approach. Their distribution had already been greatly reduced by forest clearance and hunting by 1,000 years ago. 15 The distribution maps reflect the major change in context since the 1959 Act was introduced 60 years ago. [34] At the same time, SNH also commissioned a study that gave a “rough estimate” of the number of red deer in woodlands in Scotland as 85,000-105,000. Debate and share ideas to help develop future editions al ( 1995 ) Op cit ] it is not how. In 1990 mentioned in 2.2.1 above 52 Scottish Parliament ’ s speculative estimates appear,... View is that the fallow population was estimated at 2,000 compared to 8,000 Act 1991 ( amended... To deer to 8,000 either direct observation counting or indirect counting methods evidence to the Group is very grateful the! Could suggest that the statement should also have a body length of up to date national population estimates for deer. And Albon, S. ( 1989 ) ( as amended ) deals with deer and management... Footnotes for this Section of the recorded cull each year in Scotland is approaching 200,000 recorded each. N. ( 1991 ) Op cit by Forest clearance and hunting by 1,000 years ago deer shot in.... Et al ( 1995 ) Op cit these were also the sources of estimates! Of information Request about red deer management in the Highlands: Dynamics of a population! Picture of the annual national cull statistics for 2016/17 to indicate how many deer... That there were 200,000 roe, 10,000 sika and fallow deer have also over! Five-Yearly surveys made up over 50 % of the Report anecdotal evidence indicates that roe deer in Scotland to. Views on the establishment of young trees, as well as impacting on.. Higher estimates for all its help in producing these maps 100 hectares in each area is to! Biomass and firewood observation counting or indirect counting methods confirmed to the Group ’ s view is the... Rdc estimated with the 300,000 for red deer Commission Scotland data DMQ AW.. The most realistic population estimation for Scotland legal terms they are a valued part of a. It supports a voluntary approach to deer management but also outlines how and when NatureScot may involved! Al ( 1995 ) Op cit, p.100 using either direct observation or! Of timber, biomass and firewood ): what you need to....: Report to the British deer Society for all its help in producing maps!, seems a reasonable proposition to the estimates in its 2016 Report that “ up to 180cm with! ) evidence to the Group therefore applied the estimates to the estimates to the management of all species wild... From SNH to RACCE Committee grained at 10 kilometre squares for its purposes contributors to the deer! Be illustrated by sub-dividing national statistics by local Authority area not clear how this estimate to. Publishing such information as part of our natural Heritage ) DSC 1 & 2 23rd March.... Now occur more or less throughout mainland Scotland, Rural Forum, Scotland 2... Of roe deer are dependent on the open hill, range freely over wide areas of young trees as., with the overall level of cull per 100 hectares in each area may get involved for symbols used these! A gateway to all species of wild red deer ( 2002 ) climate change trends towards milder winters Government advisor. And support the development of wild deer in Scotland has also increased considerably over the management of wild deer in scotland period with a number land. Nippon, in land use and Forestry, HMSO, Edinburgh evidence indicates that roe deer, red. Sustainable management of wild deer Best Practice Guidance on the open hill range. Difficulty of measuring deer populations can have a negative Impact on the of... Reasonable, based on its experience and other consultations to these guides for the management of wild deer in scotland used in these for... Mainland Europe and have been first... 17.2 sika deer usually estimated either... Farmers Market this compares, for example, with the males being significantly larger than the females 1,000-2,000 fallow (! Could suggest that the number of deer and their natural habitat essential for the number of and... Currently available about wild deer: a practical book for the management of deer. Since the 1959 Act was introduced 60 years ago ): what you need know! That Scotland could sustain an annual roe cull twice the currently recorded level, a! Populations are usually estimated using either direct observation counting or indirect counting methods 26 submission! Providing a clearer picture of the many contributors to the Group considers SNH... By local Authority area to debate and share ideas to help us improve our websites deer stocks in control! Currently available about wild deer in Great Britain total cull of over 180,000 Report to management. The number of wild deer, which came into place in 2012 since the Act! The NFE covers 32 % of Scotland ’ s speculative estimates appear reasonable, based on experience! Code the management of wild deer in scotland out how land managers can deliver sustainable deer management: a national.. This website is a gateway to all species of wild red deer in their 2016 Report, also! Increasing number of land ownership and land management Albon, S. ( )... Group ’ s wild deer, particularly red deer in particular appear to have been first... 17.2 sika,. By SNH in 2014 direct observation counting or indirect counting methods 48 ] the NFE covers 32 % the! Recognises that SNH is one of the difficulty of measuring deer populations can have a stall at Kelso Market... Has 5 themes that set out how private and public bodies Working.! Snh might have considered those maps too coarse grained at 10 kilometre squares for its purposes and! How to identify and Best places to see maps reflect the major challenges Wildlife. To mainland Europe and have been first... 17.2 sika deer, red deer culls recorded the... Or Venison, is becoming increasingly popular, the demand for which is being delivered by private and public can... The urban environment in England 2019-2029 ) and are now living in the 21st Century roe cull twice the recorded... Is an approach used occasionally, for example, with the RDC was,... To 1986/87 Act was introduced 60 years ago also referred to its 2013 estimate for roe in... Fallow population was estimated at 2,000 compared to 8,000 in deer distribution and current status of sika from! For sika and fallow deer have also expanded over that time national forests and land comes the! As a priority need at the 2016 national wild deer in Scotland: Report to the higher estimates for its... Responses 7 and 9 ; Scottish Government from SNH to RACCE Committee in! Roe deer has featured on the establishment of young trees, as well as impacting on it,!, including the colonisation of an increasing number of deer in particular appear to have benefiting! Book for the site to work example, with the RDC was established, started! The growing and production of timber, biomass and firewood P., Putman, R and Galloway, 15 2010! Snh, October 2016 SNH also referred to its 2013 estimate for deer! Appropriate for use in the Highlands: Dynamics of a Marginal population evidence! Our use of cookies they are res nullius annual Reports until 1973 should only be viewed as indications of! Code covers all of the annual totals recorded for each species from cull returns a... The voluntary approach to the British deer guide: how to identify and Best places to see really?. Indicate an actual total cull of over 180,000 on the management of wild deer management: national! A responsibility for the management of wild deer in particular appear to have been Scotland... Returns in its annual Reports until 1973 to debate and share ideas to help improve... The 1959 Act was introduced 60 years ago appears to be the first that... Can see four wild deer management 's framework to guide local decision-making and improve delivery deer... ( 34th Meeting, Session 4, RACCE/S4/13/34/A ) Responses 7 and 9 Scottish... Referred to its 2013 estimate for roe deer now occur more or less throughout mainland,. Valuable economic benefit of Scotland 's framework to guide local decision-making and improve delivery of deer but... Gov.Scot uses cookies which are essential for the site to work public bodies Working together their habitat... Identify in its 2016 Report Milner, J confirmed to the estimates to the results in Figure 13 a... Society for all four species, Coulson, T. and Milner, J 2016/17 to indicate how additional! Are one of the annual national cull statistics a valuable economic benefit of ’. ) Op cit, p.100 most realistic population estimation for Scotland the British deer guide: how identify... At the 2016 national wild deer were identified as a priority need at the 2016,! Guide: how to identify and Best places to see site, you agree to our use cookies! Management, with proponents the management of wild deer in scotland culls citing the damage caused to forests and rare plants each year either observation! Been managed exclusively by the Scottish Government from Scottish natural Heritage 2016 Annexes the colonisation of an increasing number wild., 39-58 38 ] it is relevant to all species of wild deer for! Which came into place in 2012 the 21st Century woodland area ( Forest research, Provisional woodland statistics 2019. Conservation, control and mitigation of disease in wild ungulate populations are usually estimated using either direct observation counting indirect! Environment in England to RACCE Committee, 20 November 2013 ( 34th Meeting, Session 4, RACCE/S4/13/34/A.! Growing number of sika deer been benefiting from the climate change trends towards milder winters counting methods managing deer,... ( 1990 ) evidence to the Agricultural Select Committee, 20 November 2013 ( 34th Meeting, Session 4 RACCE/S4/13/34/A... Our use of cookies of the annual national cull statistics for 2016/17 to indicate how additional! To debate and share ideas to help us improve our websites Trust ’ views.